Computers in the classroom

Would you think that is a good thing? Yesterday my daughter checked out a school that boasts about giving every single student her own laptop. My daughter noted that the laptops are, indeed, put to use during class. While some may actually take down notes on them, which is supposedly what they are intended for in noncomputer classes, others use it to surf the web, go on Facebook, check email, or send texts (though, admittedly they could do that anyway with just a phone). What was heralded as a tool for learning easily slips into a distraction for learning. I know that even college students would fall into distractions when they would bring laptops into class. The less mature high school students could hardly be expected to resist temptation, particularly in a school that takes a rather light approach to discipline.

You know that even when going to the moon, the scientists were still using the slide rule to make their calculations. It seems to me that the generation of long ago were not at all educationally disadvantaged by their lack of smart boards, advanced calculators, and access to the internet.

Comments

Anonymous said…
While computers can be a great tool, they can also provide an immense distraction. For a high-school, i would strongly discourage assigning a personal laptop to each student, coupled with "light" discipline and internet access, not a particularly good combination. Perhaps a more appropriate approach would be a dedicated (and supervised) computer lab for students to do research between classes. A secular studies teacher at my former high school got fired for bringing a laptop to class; one of the students discovered "content" not suitable for a yeshiva.
Ariella's blog said…
You're right that computers would be appropriate in such a lab setting. But laptops are designed to be carried beyond such contexts.

It altogether too easy to find such "content." But even if the content is not problematic in itself, it does divert their attention from what they are supposed to be learning during their biology class.
Orthonomics said…
I still opposed to overuse of calculators for math. So computers in the classroom isn't on my list of acceptable.

Popular Posts