Search This Blog
This is my blog for topics of Jewish interest, named for the magazine I created in 2005. I have been writing professionally since then and now offer shidduch profile writing services that draw on my experience as a shadchan over the past few years. Note that comment moderation is on, which could keep your comment from appearing right away.
- Get link
- Other Apps
Comments
although i assume from some of the things you wrote about the book, as well as the mere fact that he is associated with yeshivat hakibbutz hadati, that it will not be popular here.
"separately wrapped"
in an unmarked brown paper bag?
When you say, "here," you mean the US or the NY Jewish community? It actually was difficult for us to obtain. My husband's chavrusa picked it up for him on a trip to Israel, where he said many copies were available in Mea Shearim. So even the ultimate in chareidi neighborhoods had no objection to stocking it. Look, the Gemara is far from Bowlderized, and there is a definite feed for a frank presentation on the subject. I don't know if the "separately wrapped" (that was in plastic, though the brown paper would have been a nice ironic touch) section remains so in the English version. I have not seen it anywhere in the flesh, though I know it is available on the site I link to.
The problem is that in the US there is no equivalent to the dati-leumi or chardal community. For those committed to halacha there are the traditional sources; those less committed I don't think feel a need for a book like Knoll's that deals with technical halachic details. There is very little middle ground of voices who take halacha seriously but also take the needs of a modern community seriously. In America, a shayla on an eid (a bedika cloth) is either going to be addressed to a Rav by those who care or ignored by those who don't; there is little demand for an institution like the yoatzot (for example) because it services only the narrow segment of those who both take halacha seriously but at the same time want a different/better way to do things. (Rav Knoll gives the yoatzot hotline # in the book. Many if not most Rabbanim in the US I think would be wary of doing so.)
i meant here in new york. i haven't really been to other (jewish) parts of the country and comment on them.